/// HD Camcorder Comparison

Picture ?

Manufacturer

Canon

JVC

Name

HF G10

GS-TD1BE (3D-Modus)

European name ?

Legria HF G10

GS-TD1BE

US name ?

HF G10

GS-TD1

lowest US price

1249 $

1299 $

On the market since

April 2011

Manufacturers URL

Test preview

slashCAM rating ?

Very good

Satisfactory

test picture 1200 Lux

Test image 12 lux auto-mode

Video

Video formats ?

AVCHD

AVCHD
MVC 3D

Recording Medium

SD Card
SDHC card
built-in flash memory
SDXC card

SDHC card
built-in flash memory
SDXC card

video resolutions EU ?

AVCHD 1440 x 1080/50i
AVCHD 1920 x 1080/50i
AVCHD 1920 x 1080/25p
AVCHD 1440 x 1080/25p

AVCHD 1920 x 1080/50i
MP4 2 x 1920 x1080

video resolutions US ?

AVCHD 1920 x 1080/60i
AVCHD 1920 x 1080/24p
AVCHD 1440 x 1080/60i
AVCHD 1440 x 1080/24p

AVCHD 1920 x 1080/60i
MP4 2 x 1920 x1080

Max Bitrate ?

24 Mbit/s

34 Mbit/s

Compression format ?

MPEG4

on-board memory ?

32 GB

64 GB

Optics

Optics Manufacturer ?

Canon

JVC HD

Optical Zoom ?

10 x

5 x

Wide Angle 16:9 ?

30,4 mm

42 mm

Filter diameter ?

58 mm

- mm

Image Stabilization ?

optically and electronically

ND Filter ?

Digital (auto)

Exchangable optics ?

Image Sensor

Number of sensors ?

Size of image sensor ?

1/3 inch

1/4,1 inch

image sensor effective pixel count 16:9 ?

2070000 Pixel

Image Sensor Type ?

CMOS

Controls

White Balance ?

auto
manual
presets

Focus ?

auto
manual

Minimum shutter time ?

1/2.000

1/4000

Maximum shutter time ?

1/6

1/2

Apperture control ?

auto
manual
AE-Shift

auto
manual

Infrared recording ?

Expanded Focus ?

Yes

Peaking ?

Yes

Signal Processing

Zebra ?

70%
100%

Histogram ?

waveform

adjustable sharpness ?

Yes

Adjustable color ?

Yes

Cinegamma ?

Yes

Black Strech ?

Knee ?

Colorbars ?

Yes

Misc.

Shot Transition ?

Custom Presets ?

Yes

Set Time Code ?

Configuration

Connections

FBAS ?
synonymous: RCA, composite

Out

YC ?
synonymous: S-Video

YUV ?
synonymous: Component Signal

Out

HDMI ?

Out

DV / HDV (FireWire) ?
synonymous: ILink / IEEE-1394

USB ?

USB 2.0 OUT

Microphone / Audio input ?

Mini-jack

Headphones ?

Mini-jack

Lanc ?

Yes

Time-code interface ?

Genlock ?

Accessory shoe ?

Advanced Mini

Standard

HD-SDI ?

Misc.

Weight (without battery)

590 g

Weight (with battery)

676 g

Battery type

Canon BP-808

JVC BNVF815U

Battery capacity

850 mAh

1460 mAh

Charger ?

internal

Remote control

Yes

Size

Height

77 mm

102 mm

Width

77 mm

64 mm

Depth

161 mm

186 mm

Relative Size ?

Viewfinder

Viewfinder available ?

Yes

Color Viewfinder ?

Color

Viewfinder format ?

16:9

Viewfinder pixels ?

260000 Pixel

Display

Display available ?

Yes

Color display ?

Color

Display size

3,5 Inch

Display format ?

16:9

Display pixels ?

922000 Pixel

920000 Pixel

Touch Screen ?

Yes

External controls

Manual Zoom ?

Rocker

Manual Focus ?

Ring
bi-functional focus or aperture wheel

Manual Aperture ?

Wheel
bi-functional focus or aperture wheel

assignable custom key

Focus switcher ?

ND Filter ?

Exp Lock ?

Gain ?

White balance ?

Push AF ?

Audio Levels ?

Custom Keys ?
synonymous: User buttons

Audio

Audio Formats ?

Dolby AC-3 Digital 2 channel 48 KHz

Microphone ?

Stereo internal

Stereo internal
Mini-jack external

Audio Control ?

auto
manual

auto
5 steps

Audio levels ?

Viewfinder
Screen

Screen

Still

Recording Medium ?

SD Card
built-in flash memory
SDHC card
SDXC card

built-in flash memory
SDHC card
SDXC card

Medium included ?

Effective pixels ?

Resolutions ?

1920x1080

1920 x 1080 3D

Standard ?

JPEG Exif 2.2

Flash ?

Misc.

Specials

2 memory card slots

autostereoscopic display

Product Shots

View 1

View 2

Test results

Test pictures

luminance resolution

chrominance resolution

lens distortion

test small ISO image

noise / internal microphone

test picture 1200 Lux

Test image 12 lux auto-mode ?

Test image 12 lux optimized ?

slashCAM rating

Lowlight ?

Very good

Good

Resolution ?

Very good

Good

Color performance ?

Very good

Satisfactory

subj.Picture impression ?

Very good

Good

Optical Zoom ?

Sufficient

Poor

Wide Angle ?

Very good

Sufficient

Configuration / image ?

Very good

Satisfactory

Configuration / sound ?

Satisfactory

Handling ?

Good

Satisfactory

Portability ?

Very good

Good

Photo function ?

Sufficient

Satisfactory

Optics ?

Good

Satisfactory

Dynamics ?

Good

Conclusion slashCAM

slashCAM rating ?

Very good

Satisfactory

Total score ?
(maximal 570)

422

307

Pros

+ Manual control over image characteristics
+ Low-Light Properties
+ Manual buttons, wheel and lens ring
+ Touch focus in manual mode

+ More manual 3D control than its direct competitors

Cons

- ND-filter function toothless
- 4:2:2 codec is not "activated"

- operation concept
- Image characteristics can not be changed

Conclusion

In terms of manual control Canon leaves comparable consumer camcorders behind: the three custom keys, the dial and the lens ring make for the best camera operation we have seen for a long time in the price range under 1500 Euro (March 2011).The possibility to use touch focus in the manual mode is also a great plus.

In terms of image quality, handling and also the display the JVC is not quite on par with the HDR-TD10.Though the TD1 in return offers a little more manual control, this is partly hidden by an unnecessarily complicated operation.Also the non-changeable, rather extreme color settings are certainly not for everyone.A firmware update could address these criticisms, however, and make the camera much more attractive.Hopefully the standards-compliant MVC implementation will be adopted by more software makers over time.

More information

Reviews and Forums